One of my favourite quotes and a guidepost for how I view the world is: “The arc of the moral universe is long but it bends toward justice.” Martin Luther King repeated it regularly in his speeches and sermons and Barack Obama engraved it in the rug in the Oval Office. It is an optimistic world view. It recognises that humans and human institutions are flawed, even evil. We can be greedy, corrupt, power hungry, violent, racist and shockingly ignorant, BUT with the proper incentives, moral code and governing structures, we can make things better. In the long view, human history has the wind at its back and that while the process may be slow and the journey may be long, progress will happen. Fundamentally, today is better than yesterday and tomorrow will be better than today. THANK GOD!
The skeptics and cynics may challenge this sunny outlook and demand concrete examples. Well the history of the European Project from 1945 to 2014 makes my case. From the catastrophes of 1914-1945, Europe embarked on a program of rebirth, rebuilding, expansion and redemption. A quick review of the historical record is necessary. Prior to the outbreak of WWI in 1914, Europe was the center of world civilisation. It was an Imperial Age with the British, French, Russians, Austro-Hungarians and the Ottomans controlling continents. From an economic, military and cultural perspective, Europe was the center of the universe. The leaders of this world order then embarked on the greatest example of civilisational suicide in world history. WWI destroyed the existing international order. 18 million people were killed in a bloody industrial warfare- machine guns, artillery, poison gas, senseless trench warfare- an unprecedented carnage. The Russian, German, Austro-Hungarian Empires collapsed. Pre war Europe’s abiding faith in progress was shattered.
This moronic war was then followed by a “bad peace.” Versailles was a disaster. Germany was forced to admit war guilt, stripped of territory and saddled with crippling reparations. German nationalists, particularly the Nazis exploited this reality. New countries were created with multi ethnic populations and built in tensions. The League of Nations lacked enforcement powers and the United States refused to join and embraced isolationism. The economic depression of the late 1920’s destroyed the middle class. There was a 70% collapse in international trade as tariff walls rose. Unemployment reached 30% in Germany and 20% in Britain during the depression. Germany experienced hyperinflation. Globalisation, which had flourished form 1900-1914, reversed entirely as nations turned inward. Political extremism filled the vacuum. Mussolini’s Fascists seized power in Italy, Hitler and the Nazis grabbed power in Germany in 1933. Stalin and the Communists ruled the Soviet Union with an iron fist; forced collectivisation created the Great Famine in Ukraine and the Great Terror killed millions more. The brutal Spanish Civil War from 1936-1939 was a bitter ideological struggle that served as a dress rehearsal for WWII. The Second World War then completed the destruction of Europe. There were 85 million deaths. 14% of the Soviet population perished. The Holocaust was a genocide that murdered 6 million Jews, three quarters of the Jewish population that had lived in Europe prior to the war. It was “Total War” and civilians were targeted from the outset. When it ended in 1945, we saw an entirely different international profile. The United States and the Soviet Union were victorious superpowers. 31 years of insanity had reduced Europe from global master to vassals of either the Americans or the Russians. Great Britain, a purported “winner”, was actually broke and was forced to give up its colonial possessions in short order. France was humiliated. Germany was in ashes. Populations had been displaced, families destroyed, economies shattered and there was no recognisable remaining political order. Finally, the very idea of European moral authority was discredited. How could a civilisation that produced Auschwitz claim any leadership role. Europe had reached an absolute nadir.
YET, this destroyed, confused and debased continent would then produce one of history’s most remarkable transformations. From 1945 to 2014, Europe made deliberate policy choices designed to accelerate economic progress and to ensure that the horrors of war would never return. They built a “new” Europe based on concrete principles. First, nations would be governed by democratically elected leaders. There would be free and fair elections. Authoritarianism and tyranny were sent to the dustbin of history. Second, societies would be structured under the Rule of Law. The application of arbitrary power, force, unjust imprisonment and torture were out. Third, the promotion and protection of individual human rights was enshrined in constitutions and legislation. Freedom of religion, speech and assembly were codified. Fourth, they embraced diplomacy as the means to settle disputed between nations. They abided by the UN charter recognising the sacredness of borders. Fifth, they openly expressed a commitment to multilateral institutions. Global issues should be resolved by global debate, dialogue and cooperation. The United Nations, the World Health Organization, the World Trade Organization, the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund and the European Union itself are all products of this philosophy. It was a coherent and interlocking series of choices that put Europe on the path to the most successful experience of peace, prosperity and integration in human history. Ancient enemies became partners.
Turning these principles into action was not automatic. Three pillars were critical to European renewal. The first is security. NATO and the American guarantee are absolutely critical to the success of the “project.” NATO was created in 1949 and is a revolutionary break from Europe’s history of shifting alliances and balance of power politics. Article 5 of the treaty is a collective defence guarantee, an attack on one country is and attack on all. For the first time, the United States committed to a permanent peacetime engagement in European security. Europe was shielded form any Soviet attack by the American nuclear umbrella and the presence of American military bases in NATO countries. The underlying premise behind NATO was described by a pundit at the time of its creation: “Keep the United States In, Keep the Russians Out and Keep the Germans down. It worked and has worked now for 75 years. The second pillar is economic integration and a European Common Market. The 1951 Coal and Steel Community placed German and French production under shared authority. The 1957 Treaty of Rome created the European Economic Community with free movement of goods, capital and labor. Living standards soared and the major countries in western Europe were rivaling America’s economic performance by the late 1980’s. Pillar 3 was a transatlantic partnership that went far beyond security and NATO. There was cultural convergence and an alliance based on values. The Marshall Plan provided Europe 150 billion in today’s dollars and was a wise investment and policy by the United States- not simply charity. It linked the players across the board and was a genuinely reciprocal relationship. All should remember that Europe provided bases and intelligence cooperation in the Cold War struggle and the Western Europe became an attractive alternative to Soviet controlled Eastern Europe. Lifting millions of people out of poverty and preserving the peace was essential to the US victory in the Cold War with the Soviet Union. By 1989, Western Europe could hold its head high. 44 years without a major war was unprecedented in modern history. The Berlin Wall fell in 1989. Democracy had been consolidated even where it had previously failed- in Germany and Italy. Ancient hatreds had been transcended through shared institutions and collective security. KUDOS!!
The winning streak continued form 1989 to 2014. Consolidation, expansion redemption and victory were the operative principles. The collapse of the Soviet Union opened an opportunity to extend the Western European miracle eastward. The Maastricht Treaty in 1992 created the European Union, a political and monetary union with a governing superstructure in Brussels. The Euro currency was launched in 1999, a profound statement of mutual commitment and shared destiny. 13 countries joined the EU: Poland, Hungary, Czech Republic, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Romania, Bulgaria and Croatia. It was far more than a geographic expansion. It was a civilizational choice for economic freedom, social safety nets, democracy and the rule of law. For former Warsaw Pact nations, EU membership meant they could never be dragged back into Russia’s orbit. NATO expanded on a parallel track. Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic signed in 1999 and were followed in later rounds by Slovakia, Slovenia, Romania, Bulgaria, Albania, Croatia, Montenegro and North Macedonia. Article 5 was invoked for the United States after September 11, 2001 and Europe troops served in Afghanistan. Things were looking good, but fractures, tensions and war over the past 12 years have engendered a major crisis. Can Europe maintain its momentum or is the post WWII international order DEAD? The stakes are high. What happened?
The entire world has experienced a series of shocks in the 21st century. Everyone has needed to revisit their assumptions and expectations, but the stress levels are extraordinarily high in Europe. The world has become more violent since 2001. Violent conflicts, whether outright wars, civil wars or acts of terrorism are at their highest level since 1945. Immigration crises, particularly since 2015 have dramatically changed the political debates in the United States and Europe. The 2008-2009 economic crisis undermined the post war consensus on the wisdom and solidity of the American new liberal model. Brexit in 2016 shocked the European Union. The election of Donald Trump and the rise of right wing populist parties in Europe shattered the post WWII consensus on democracy, rule of law, human rights and multilateralism. Basically, a challenge to the entire project. COVID was major disruption and undermined confidence in the public health system and government generally. Putin invaded Ukraine- a shameless and fundamental challenge to the overriding international principle that borders cannot be altered by force. China has exploded as economic and military superpower. Lots of moving parts here.
The wildly successful European experiment is now facing huge challenges. In 2026, it is a continent at the crossroads. There is a demographic collapse. Fertility is well below replacement in ALL European countries. Population is projected to decline by 30% by 2050. 40% of all Europeans will be over 65 by 2050. A shrinking working age population will need to support a growing retiree population. Healthcare and pension systems will face cutbacks or insolvency. Fewer births means fewer scientists, innovators and artists and a shrinking society is less productive and dynamic. Investments in necessary infrastructure and research and development projects will erode. Democracy is under assault by populist movements. Economies are stagnant and Europe is far behind in digital technology and artificial intelligence. None of the top ten tech companies are based in Europe. Fragmented markets and risk averse venture capital starves European tech entrepreneurs of funding. There is a persistent brain drain with Oxford trained talent choosing to work for Google or Meta. The popular adage is that “America creates and innovates, China imitates and grows, the EU taxes and regulates.” The European Union is stagnant and whether 27 nations can hold together is a legitimate question. Brexit was the first crack but Euroskeptics are growing in influence in France and Germany. Immigration is the best method to draw tech talent and fight the demographic collapse, but immigration is toxic and has become the third rail of European politics. NO political party supports increased immigration. More dangerous, the ascendant right wing populist parties often define EU principles like the rule of law, commitment to human rights, press freedoms and judicial independence as violations of national sovereignty. Illiberal democracy is on the march.
Finally, the crisis in the US-EUROPE transatlantic relationship deserved its own paragraph (or essay!). A painful reckoning is staring us in the face. America has been unhappy with Europe free riding on American security guarantees for decades but President Trump certainly raised the temperature on this issue. Most European NATO members had let their militaries atrophy, missing the 2% defence spending target and their structural weakness was revealed when Putin invaded Ukraine and European arsenals were quickly depleted. Ultimately, the Biden administration provided the vast majority of military support and weaponry. Trump demanded NATO countries to commit to defence spending increases to a level of 3 to 5 percent of GDP. BUT, he went further. His basic message is that America’s security guarantee is transitional and conditional. Trump does not see NATO as a mutually beneficial sacred alliance, but as a “protection racket” where Europeans aren’t paying their bills. He has publicly questioned the enforceability of the Article 5 security commitment and has repeatedly floated withdrawing the United States from NATO entirely. He has de facto abandoned Ukraine and is more interested in cultivating business relationships with Russia. He has also destroyed the economic relationship with Europe. A system of shared prosperity is now seen as a zero sum game. For 70 years, America encouraged European prosperity as serving its own interests. Trump now views Europe prosperity as coming at America’s expense and has stated that the EU was created to “screw” the United States. He has imposed tariffs on early all European goods and constantly threatens Europe with economic warfare. The post war consensus that free trade serves both partners has been explicitly rejected. The bottom line is that one of the foundations of the post war liberal order, the integrated transatlantic economy, has been deliberately and unilaterally fractured by the United States.
The break with Europe authored by the Trump administration is not simply a policy choice. I submit it is an existential break. The reality is that Trump and MAGA are more comfortable with Putin and other autocrats than with an EU based on the rule of law and human rights. Trump’s Washington openly favours right wing populist movements over mainstream Euro center- right or centre-left political parties. They embrace Germany’s AFD, Hungary’s Fidesz, Farage in the United Kingdom and Marie Le Pen in France. The “National Security Strategy” published by the Trump administration accuses the European governments as purging “civilisational erasure” through migration and free speech policies. The mainstream Europeans are “woke”- Putin is “one of us.” Insane, but a recent article confirmed that a poll of European NATO leaders confirmed that NONE of them had absolute confidence that the Trump Administration would fulfill their obligations under Article 5 if Putin attacked a NATO member. Any hard nosed observer would conclude the transatlantic alliance no longer exists and that the post WWII international order is not simply in crisis- it has been destroyed. We are witnessing a 21st century version of civilisational suicide. SAD. I am skeptical of optimists who say things will return to normal after the departure of Trump. If I were a European, I would not trust the United States. Trust is hard earned and critical to any important relationship- family, societal, political. BUT, once trust is lost, it is hard to regain. The Europeans need to develop strategic autonomy. Pursue military strength, economic competitiveness and invest in technology and innovation. Confront democratic backsliding. The reality is that Europe united can be a major global force, but that European nations alone are weak and irrelevant. Accept that reality and act with confidence. If America insists everything is transactional, respond accordingly and protect your own interests. There are some positive signs. BREXIT was a predictable answer and a majority in the UK want to rejoin the EU. Orban lost in Hungary. NATO is now buttressed by Sweden and Finland as members. All is not lost.